The Ghosts of Hamilton House B&B

October 3, 2019

As I’m sure you can imagine, Whitewater, WI’s old Victorian mansion on Main St., Hamilton House B&B, offers its fair share of creaks and groans, but as the weather cools and the winds shift, the ghostly legend of the B&B arises again and begs to be told.

In the late 1800s, the Van Gieson/Posey family purchased the house. Sarah Posey, daughter of Van Gieson, taught art lessons out of the home and even inlaid a few hand painted tiles into the woodwork of the grand staircase while her father tiled the facing of the fireplace in the dining room, including two tiles in the upper corners that featured the faces of Sarah and her son (Little Boy Posey). Legend has it that Sarah and her son were very happy, but Sarah’s husband, Oliver Posey, wanted to get rich quick. Only a handful of years later, the family sold the home, took off to California, and were never seen back in Whitewater (alive) again.

Hand painted tile inlaid in the grand staircase of the Hamilton House B&B: Whitewater, WI

The house suffered under new owner after new owner throughout the early 1900s, and in the 1950s, it fell into disrepair. Walls and flooring needed to be redone, and it was noted that the tile of Little Boy Posey’s portrait was missing from the fireplace. Every resident of the house reported seeing a woman in her nightgown out in the East Gardens.

The East Gardens of the Hamilton House B&B: Whitewater, WI

When the house became a fraternity in the 1960s/70s, students frequently saw a little boy at the foot of their beds in the middle of the night. They described him as an annoying kid who acted like a little brother who needed attention. His favorite room was his mother’s at the top of the stairs, today’s Deluxe Room, the Pissarro. One man was so disturbed by Little Boy Posey’s constant presence that he never stepped foot in the Hamilton House again.

Hamilton House B&B Deluxe Room, the Camille Pissarro, once Sarah Posey’s bedroom: Whitewater, WI

After the fraternity shut down, the back hallway of the house was turned into a doll museum. The museum owners constantly found dolls moved around, placed on chairs, and on the floor in the middle of the hallway. They guessed it was Little Boy Posey trying to get their attention.

Back hallway of the Hamilton House B&B that once housed a doll museum: Whitewater, WI

Once the house finally underwent major renovations, the missing tile of the son’s face was suddenly found out in the East Garden where Sarah always stood. It was returned to the facing of the fireplace, and both ghosts were never seen again.

Current Owner, Kathleen Witham Fleming, recently met with distant relatives of the Poseys to share the story of the ghosts and learn more about their family history. It has been believed that Little Boy Posey died of small pox and Sarah of heartache, but they both actually lived long lives and died in old age. After passing, their bodies were returned to Whitewater and buried in Hillside Cemetery. Kathleen believes that the ghosts returned to the place where life was the happiest.

“Our legend is short and sweet. I like that we have a ghost story that’s benign…and that they’re gone.” *laughs*

Kathleen Witham Fleming, Owner and Innkeeper of Hamilton House B&B

If you want to hear more ghost stories and local spooky lore like this, tickets are still available for Spirit Tour October 11th and 12th. Indulge in a guided tour around town and immerse yourself in the spiritualism presence that gave Whitewater the nickname, “Second Salem.”

Get our Newsletter!

By clicking "Sign Up" I agree to the Terms of Service.